Nick Viall is no stranger to criticisms. He was bashed for questioning Bachelorette season 10 star Andi Dorfman on national TV why they made love in the fantasy suite if she didn’t love him, was condemned for pursuing Bachelorette star Kaitlyn Bristowe in the middle of season 11 and slept with her during their first one-on-one date and then somewhat redeemed himself when he showed up for the third season of Bachelor in Paradise .